The former officer appealed his termination to the City Managers Office, and Assistant City Manager Rod Wensing, in a Nov. 12 written order, upheld Ticers decision. All rights reserved. Still unable to disengage his safety, Ashepulled out his 9 mm semiautomatic pistol and shot at Pierce multiple times. Data last updated September 6, 2022. The Eighth Judicial District Critical Incident Response Team, or CIRT, handled theinvestigationinto both Harding's death and the police shooting that killed Pierce, withLarimer County Sheriff's Office servingas the lead investigating agency. %%EOF He did not immediately provide the name of the lawyers hired by the city. Ashe twisted Sowl's arm. LOVELAND, Colo. A 59-year-old woman was killed in an exchange of gunfire with members of the Loveland Police Department's (LPD) SWAT team, according to police. Ashe was not involved in Garners arrest nor was he named in that lawsuit. The suit claims that Ashe was fired on that day for asking a records technician to do a search of reports involving Sgt. Due to concerns an armed suspect or other victims might be in the home, six members of the Loveland SWAT team responded to the house, arriving at 8:45 p.m. Thats why its so important to That great looking new building in Wiggins? Paul Ashe. Harding's mother told police there were guns and a dog in the couple's house, located at 3376 Cuchara Court. Phil Metzler and the 2020 arrest of Karen Garner, though Ashe was not involved in that investigation or case in any way. The Eighth Judicial District Critical Incident Response Team, or CIRT, handled theinvestigation, the Critical Incident Response Team investigates police shootings in Larimer County, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. Former officer Daria Jalali also faces misdemeanor charges regardingher role in the arrest. The Defendants also aver that the . An internal review determined the officer was not justified in arresting a witness who refused to answer his questions. Brockton police arrest 16 in prostitution sting. The SWAT members who fired their weapons were placed on paid administrative leave in accordance with Loveland Police Department policy. Loveland Police Department identifies officer who shot alleged Subway robber Loveland police officer Paul Ashe has been identified as the on-duty officer who shot Gavin Gamez on Monday after Gamez allegedly robbed a Subway restaurant. The city settled that suit for $290,000, and according to previous reporting by the Reporter-Herald, a separate police department internal investigation found Ashe violated department policy surrounding use of force, limits of authority and search and seizure. "Based on these findings as well as several messages Tammy Pierce sent to family members," investigators concluded that Pierce shot Harding with the gun sometime between Nov. 6 and Nov. 8. A former Loveland police officer pleaded not guilty Thursday to charges alleging he assaulted a woman during an arrest in summer 2020, then downplayed his use of force in the arrest report.. Ashe arrested Sowl for obstruction of justice and resisting arrest, but the 8th Judicial District Attorney's Office dismissed the charges, according to the lawsuit. Dont grab that gun. Officer Ashe came to the Loveland Police Department from the Colorado State University Police Department. It's official: Jamal Murray, Nuggets are in Phoenix's heads now. The wrongful termination case filed by former Loveland Police Department officer Paul Ashe filed against the. "If it had not been for the ballistic helmet, which Officer Ashe was wearing, Office Ashe would have been killed or seriously injured," Riedel wrote. A little more than an hour later, at 8:30 p.m., members of the SWAT team entered the residence and encountered a Tammy Pierce, 59, armed with a firearm. 2023 www.coloradoan.com. Hewas not seriously injured. Published: Feb. 26, 2021 at 11:17 AM PST. Those actions, according to the suit, were determined to be a violation of department policy. Prior to entering the home, Ashe looked inside the front door but told investigators he did not see any people. DA Decision ***Originally Posted read more Police Unity Tour Completed! excessive force lawsuit that resulted in a $290,000 settlement by the city in January 2021. When he was unable to contact anyone at the front door, he walked around the exterior of the house, knocking on doors and looking in windows. Officer Paul Ashe justified for stopping armed robbery suspect Friends and Family, Please review the District Attorney's decision regarding Officer Paul Ashe's incident where he stopped an armed suspect. Attorneys representing both sides Reid Elkus on behalf of Ashe and Peter Doherty on behalf of the city appeared in court virtually Wednesday afternoon where 8th Judicial District Court Judge Joseph Findley scheduled a case management conference at 8:30 a.m. May 20. Ashe was previously named in an excessive force lawsuit brought against LPD and several officers by resident Preston Sowl, stemming from Sowls arrest in 2019. Pierce started to crawl on her hands and knees toward the pistol and was within reach of the pistol when Metzler released a police K-9. When it comes to landscape Did you know Your Butcher, Frank has super tasty delicatessen salads? The city of Loveland has not filed a response in court, and City Attorney Moses Garcia said he could not comment on pending litigation. Pierce, 59, was shot and killed on Nov. 11 by the Loveland Police SWAT Team members, whoresponded to her home near Mehaffey Parkto investigate a reported homicide. SUGGESTED VIDEOS | Local stories from 9NEWS. PUBLISHED: October 18, 2021 at 6:05 p.m. | UPDATED: October 18, 2021 at 6:06 p.m. Loveland's Police Department confirmed officer Paul Ashe has been on unpaid administrative leave for at. 1.1 Loveland Colorado Police Department; 2 Incident Reports. We have engaged outside counsel who will be representing the city in this matter, said Garcia. More; Page actions. . >>r, V94)zt{{,,j{"J6QIE=PK/~aWe:.8+TMDfI7VEc0p~LYq%$v PY}_[o`/LZdvYoot9fEKi;g8dyZ9s4,fVrVP,f45!-%Nt]'`S/sq>_ WZtdUSL8M\*acF! Master Sergeant Metzler began his law enforcement career with the Evans Police Department. Email him at, previously identified as Paul Ashe, Mat Grashorn andPhil Metzler. As Ashe attempted to disengage the safety on his police rifle, Pierce grabbed the pistol and fired one shot. However, Hacker said he could not provide any further details about Ashes situation and would not offer any examples or reasons why an officer would be placed on unpaid leave. He was evaluated at the scene and medically cleared. The video below is police bodycam footage from the incident. Si vous souhaitez personnaliser vos choix, cliquez sur Grer les paramtres de confidentialit. At approximately 7:20 p.m., Loveland officer Scott Walker went to the residence for a second check. Officers Paul Ashe, Mathew Grashorn and Philip Metzler were justified in killing Tammy Pierce because they tried to use less-than-lethal force before they opened fire and because they faced a . The release did not state what disciplinary or corrective action would be taken as a result of this internal investigation, just that any disciplinary actions would be taken in accordance with the conclusion and outcome of the IA., More:Colorado Supreme Court ruling makes more police internal investigations accessible. Harding's mother told police that Pierce had called her three days prior and indicatedthat she had killed Harding. . He has asked a jury to reverse Police Chief Bob Ticers decision in October to fire him, and to award him back pay and compensation for lost benefits. The lawsuit alleges officers injured Garner when they arrested her in June 2020 for alleged petty theft. Keeler: Chris Paul got dirty. Si vous ne souhaitez pas que nos partenaires et nousmmes utilisions des cookies et vos donnes personnelles pour ces motifs supplmentaires, cliquez sur Refuser tout. Colorado lawmakers "belly flop" on water crisis, opting for further study of Colorado River over action, experts say, Colorado property tax relief: Polis, lawmakers reveal plan to ease skyrocketing tax bills, Kiszla: Avs embarrass themselves with silence about Valeri Nichushkin's mysterious absence following reported 9-1-1 call, Images, suicide note released in mall massacre, Avalanche's Stanley Cup defense sputters to end in Game 7 of first round vs. underdog Seattle Kraken, Kraken-Avs Game 7 Quick Hits: Philipp Grubauer gets last laugh on Colorado fans, Avs, Ask Amy: A gentleman ponders gender salutations, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. ", More:Fort Collins man sues Loveland police officer, alleges wrongful DUI arrest. Ashe was not involved in the civil lawsuit filed by the Garner family. He said that the same administrative policies that all officers are required to follow require Ticer to issue a final written warning and said the department head, in this case the chief, shall consult with human resources on any such decision. Officer Mat Grashorn, a five-year veteran of the Loveland Police Department. Ashe was involved in two Loveland Police Department in 2019: The f police of Tammy Pierce, who . 240 0 obj <>stream Larimer County District Attorney Cliff Riedel has ruled that three Loveland police officers were justified in fatally shootinghomicide suspect Tammy Pierce in her west Loveland home last month. In October, city spokesperson Tom Hacker told the Coloradoan that Ashe had been placed on unpaid leave as a result of the Garner internal affairs investigation.. Keeler: Avs fans, could we please skip Valeri Nichushkin, Nazem Kadri revisionist history? Its the new home of High Plains Bank in Wiggins. Still outside the door, he saw a hand being raised from anindividual crouched and still obscured from view. Denver officers shoot suspect in barricade situation, police say, Isolated storms Tuesday; 70s here to stay. Loveland police officer named in Preston Sowl, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Loveland police officer named in Preston Sowl lawsuit put on unpaid leave, Loveland, Berthoud law enforcement arrests: criminal mischief, DUI, Man arrested after shots fired Saturday night outside Budweiser Events Center, Loveland, Berthoud police calls: Disturbances, shoplifting, Loveland, Berthoud law enforcement calls: Multiple crashes, Brought to you by Prairie Mountain Publishing, REO Speedwagon coming to Loveland on Nov. 17, Larimer County restaurant inspections made April 12-21, 2023, McWhinney to relinquish surface rights on formerly proposed Centerra South oil pad site if urban renewal plan is approved, New Loveland trail south of Boyd Lake to officially open Tuesday, First Street reopens in downtown Loveland, Northern Colorado veterans take off on Honor Flight, Loveland City Council gives mixed reviews to possible sales tax for fire safety, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. The lawsuit claims Ashe was fired because he was not an employee of the Police Department who has been trained in the use of the records management system and therefore was not authorized to query this information.. Its the new home of High Plains Bank in Wiggins. hb```e``2``a``eg@ ~f$OD5V?skcv0a+s?CGX~7B;@ ]8x*]3Gf29 Ou6OtGG:H#a`%>&0(up=B&#Nj]1cf2 t The lawsuit, which was filed on Dec. 16, claims that Ticer decided to fire Ashe on Oct. 1 for allegedly violating a department policy on records access. Thebullets matched those shot at the officers as well as unfired ammunition found in the home. Have a story idea, send it his way. Sowl and several other people lifted the bike off of the man and called 911. City Manager Steve Adams directed questions to human resources director Julia Holland, who said the incident was a personnel concern and, as such, no further information could be released. Loveland resident who filed a lawsuit against Loveland and four police of ficers, Paul Ashe, Benjamin Delima, Clint Schnorr and Brian Bartnes, last year in which he alleged that they violated his constitutional rights by detaining and injuring him after he declined to talk to them while at the scene of an accident in September 2019 . The 8th Judicial District Attorney's Office announced Friday that Loveland Police Department officer Paul Ashe was justified in shooting Gavin Gamez on April 29, after Gamez allegedly held. He said he heard hersay, I am already dead., Metzler told investigators he heard Pierce also say, Kill me, kill me., At the time, the officers didn't know if she was an armed suspect involved in the death of the man in the garageor a victim. The spacious, modern Pamela Johnson is an award-winning journalist with two decades invested in the community of Loveland. Ashe twisted Sowls arm behind his back and pushed his face into the ground, according to a civil rights lawsuit.